PEREIRA, E. U.; http://lattes.cnpq.br/4871111235927579; PEREIRA, Elaine Urbano.
Abstract:
Certain legal norms, such as the 1988 Federal Constitution, the Elderly Statute, and the
National Elderly Policy, establish the obligations of care, support, and mutual protection
that should be present in the relationships between parents and children. The failure to
comply with these obligations can be considered as emotional abandonment, which may
lead to compensation for moral damages in the civil sphere. In light of this, the present
work aims to discuss the general possibility of civil redress for the harms suffered by the
elderly who are abandoned by their children. Regarding specific objectives, it is
considered that it is not the "duty to love" that should be imposed but the duty to care;
identify legal provisions that uphold the rights of the elderly abandoned by their children;
and point out the consequences of emotional abandonment. To achieve these objectives,
the methodology uses the deductive method, following bibliographical and documentary
technical procedures, with an overall descriptive objective, employing a qualitative
approach. The study begins by questioning how the state took on the responsibility of
caring for the elderly, the historical evolution, and the emergence of the rights of this
segment of the population, also delving into the concept of the term elderly and making
considerations about the importance of constitutional principles, with an emphasis on
Family Law. It then addresses crucial points of civil responsibility, presenting
conceptualization, evolution, distinctions between subjective and objective theories, and
assumptions. Finally, it defines emotional abandonment, emphasizing especially the
aforementioned abandonment of children towards their elderly parents, examining
elements that substantiate the application of moral damages and the obligation to provide
sustenance and support, and the imposition of civil liability on those who fail to provide
this support, also highlighting Bill No. 4,294/2008, which is currently under
consideration. In conclusion, despite being a highly relevant topic, the existing legal
systems for addressing this issue are insufficient. However, it is evident that emotional
abandonment of elderly parents is gaining attention and acceptance, considering previous
cases in the STJ that accepted compensation when the victim is a child. Taking this into
account, when dealing with the same case, in reverse, proving this abandonment of elderly
parents can also justify compensation for the damages caused.